A warm neutral living-room corner with a linen armchair beside a picture window overlooking a rain-fresh wooded Mill Valley garden.

What Last Winter Tells a Mill Valley Home Buyer About the Months Ahead

  • November 19, 2026

Thanksgiving is a week away. If last year holds, the flow of new listings across Marin will nearly stop within a few weeks. In December 2025, 59 new residential listings came onto the BAREIS MLS countywide. In March 2026 the count was 402. In Mill Valley, average days on market climbed to 59 for homes that closed in December 2025 and 75 for homes that closed in January 2026.

Long day counts in a thin month say more about which homes were left to sell than about a discount. Over the same stretch, Mill Valley's average sale prices in December and January stayed close to fall levels.

In December, the Shortage Is on the Seller's Side

Supply drops first. Marin had 107 new residential listings in November 2025 and 59 in December. In January 2026 the count rose to 191.

Sales held up much better than listings. Marin closed 151 residential sales in December 2025, more than twice the number of new listings that month, and the median days on market for those sales was 51. The California Association of Realtors tracks a measure that compares homes for sale with the pace of sales. For Marin single-family homes it stood at 1.5 months in December 2025, a tight reading. It then jumped to 3.8 months in January 2026 as new listings came back faster than sales, according to C.A.R.'s January 2026 release.

So in December, the shortage was on the seller's side of the table. Buyers who were still searching had very few homes to choose from.

Why the Day Count Climbs When Fewer Homes Arrive

Days on market for a closed sale counts back to the date the home was listed. A Mill Valley home that closed in January 2026 most likely went under contract in December or earlier. With so few homes listed in December, the closings in those weeks have to draw on a smaller pool, and a longer average means more of those sales had been listed for a while.

The numbers line up with that. Mill Valley recorded 14 residential sales in December 2025 at an average of 59 days, and six residential sales in January 2026 at an average of 75 days. In February 2026 the average fell to 44 days across 17 sales. A month with six sales can swing on two or three slow listings. The winter day count says more about how long the remaining homes had been listed than about how buyers felt.

That matters when a buyer is weighing a specific house. A Mill Valley listing that has been on the market since October is a different kind of opportunity from one that appears the week after New Year's, and a citywide average mixes the two.

Winter Averages Sat Level With the Fall; Spring Was the Outlier

The Mill Valley figures below come from the BAREIS monthly closed sales by area reports, which list average prices for residential sales in each town. They are averages over fairly small counts, so a single large sale can move a month.

Month Mill Valley residential sales Average sale price Average days on market
November 2025 23 $2,191,739 28
December 2025 14 $2,170,492 59
January 2026 6 $2,368,625 75
February 2026 17 $2,194,576 44
March 2026 23 $2,491,935 27
April 2026 38 $2,668,134 21
May 2026 34 $3,087,088 9
June 2026 39 $2,359,574 21
July 2026 22 $2,216,364 42
August 2026 16 $2,204,063 27
September 2026 20 $2,161,200 17
October 2026 38 $2,307,013 31

Eight of the twelve months fall between about $2.16 million and $2.37 million. December 2025, the slowest month for new listings, averaged $2,170,492. September 2026, a busy fall month, averaged $2,161,200. If winter brought real discounts, December should sit well below September. It sits almost level with it.

The months that stand out are April and May 2026. May's 34 Mill Valley sales added up to $104,961,000, an average just above $3 million, and those homes averaged nine days on market. By June the average was back to $2,359,574. A jump that steep, followed by a quick return within a month, is more consistent with a different set of homes closing in May than with a citywide price increase that then reversed.

For a buyer looking in the $2 million range, this changes the decision. On this record, the December and January averages sat close to the October and September ones, and the spring high came and went within a few months.

Where This Fall Stands Going Into the Holidays

Mill Valley had a strong October. BAREIS recorded 38 residential sales in October 2026, totaling $87,666,500, at an average of $2,307,013 and 31 days on market. That matches the 38 sales in April 2026. Countywide, Marin added 241 new residential listings in October 2026, down from 341 in September.

The county also has less on the market than it did a year ago. C.A.R.'s September 2026 release put Marin's single-family active listings down 32.1% from September 2025, tied for the largest decline among the counties it tracks. The same release reported a Marin median of $1,678,750 for September 2026 and an inventory measure of 2.2 months, compared with 3.4 months in September 2025, with a median time on market of 56.5 days.

If new listings fall off in December the way they did last year, that drop will start from a lower county inventory than last year's did.

Choosing Between a Winter Search and a Spring Search

A winter search in Mill Valley gives a buyer a short list, fewer competing buyers on any one home, and prices that, on last year's record, track the fall. A home with a long day count should be judged on its own history: its list date, any price changes, and why it did not sell earlier.

A spring search gives far more choice and much faster sales. Marin's new listings run several times higher, and Mill Valley's May 2026 sales went from list to sale in an average of nine days. Spring buyers often face competing offers, and our guide to preparing a Mill Valley home for competitive offers covers that market from the seller's side. For a broader look at the town itself, see the Mill Valley neighborhood page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Mill Valley homes cheaper in December and January? On the 2025–26 record, not in any consistent way. Mill Valley's average residential sale price was $2,170,492 in December 2025 and $2,368,625 in January 2026, close to the fall 2026 averages of $2,161,200 in September and $2,307,013 in October.

Why use averages instead of the median? The BAREIS town-level monthly reports publish sales counts, total sales value, average price and average days on market for each town. Median figures are published at the county level.

When do new listings come back after the holidays? In January. Marin's new residential listings rose from 59 in December 2025 to 191 in January 2026, then reached 402 in March.

Whether you are looking at a Mill Valley listing that has been on the market since fall or deciding whether to list your own home in January or wait for spring, Kris Klein can show you how comparable homes on your street have sold this year, month by month. To find out where your home fits on this year's record, request a home valuation.

Work With Kris

Whether you're a buyer or a seller, my experience with tough negotiations will help successfully close your deal in the competitive Marin market, and you can be confident that you're in excellent hands.